An opinion you're probably all alone with?

[Anteros]

No.

The game requires the player to perform an active interaction (line up the attack with the target). That is the test of whether the attack hits. If the player aims properly, they hit, if they fail to line up the attack correctly they miss.

You only get one. Either the player's physical interaction with the game, or a random number generator. Not both for the same action.

But that's such a brain dead easy interaction that it's useless as a metric. It's like saying players should always hit in d&d if they manage to roll their dice. It's not a test of the player's skill so much as the base requirement for interacting with the game.