Originally Posted by
Taffimai
This is exactly the same, from town's pov, whether they kill the real one or the fake one. Both dead including guaranteed 1 wolf at the expenditure of one elimination and one NK, with the added risk that Snake speaks up to save the town Crow so two live verified PRs vs one dead wolf. You've also now given a reason for why you could be a wolf ccing. No offense, but if we kill Illven, I will not believe your information until Snake speaks up anyway, and I hope they won't do so until much later in the game.
You are right that tomorrow, the fake will be a dead wolf walking. Pushing for town to kill one of you now, thus potentially wasting two eliminations to catch our 1 wolf, is not a pro-town plan and denies us information the real one could give in the coming days. The only downside I see to leaving you both alive is that Badger can almost guaranteed join the wolf team - but that gives them tmi and might make it easier to flush them out as well.
Afaic you can both live until we know. Other people are free to vote differently.