The Index of the Giant's Comments VI―Making Dogma from Zapped Bananas

[Jasdoif]

I think the main takeaway from #9 is not "I don't read the forums anymore" (which is not new information), but rather "uh yeah maybe take my forum posts with a grain of salt"

That's not new information either, though.

This is why I'm sorta starting to hate the out-of-context quoting; because I tend to exaggerate when speaking extemporaneously and describe things out of proportion to what I really intended when I wrote the scenes. I should learn to just stop talking about it, because everytime I say something I end up changing everyone's view of the events in the story, and I would be better served letting the story stand on its own and ignoring the critics.

And, given the borderline histrionics that occurred when the Giant asked us not to index posts outside the OotS subforum unless they had something to do with OotS (which was only three months before the quoted section above), I'm a bit leery of trying to focus on the subject.

Still, what's everyone else think?

I won't go into semantics in this thread, I'm only asking that the quote not be summarized as, "No."

I have a distaste for extrapolation when it comes to the entry descriptions, if that's what you're asking.

As truly minor note: could you change the crusader id to F1? P being both initial of "post" and "patreon" is not helping.

Done.

---

So that brings us to....

#	Question	In Favor	Against	Disposition	Posters
1	How do you feel about OOTS remaining (D&D) 3.5? Great.	4	2	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Kish, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Grey_Wolf_c, Gwynfrid
2	What makes a good magic system? Lack of bad drama.	5	1	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Gwynfrid, Kish, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Grey_Wolf_c
3	Would you ever appear on a tabletop gaming stream? No.	4	3	Vote-able	In Favor: Gwynfrid, Kish, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Aidan, Grey_Wolf_c, Metastachydium
4	Is the Open Gaming License an issue for the comic? No.	4	4	Vote-able	In Favor: Gwynfrid, Kish, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Aidan, Grey_Wolf_c, Metastachydium, b_jonas
5	Why is your Patreon avatar Elan? Representative accuracy.	5	2	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Gwynfrid, Kish, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Grey_Wolf_c, Metastachydium
6	How did you pick which Norse Gods made it into the Northern Pantheon? Matching names to reasons.	6	1	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Gwynfrid, Kish, Metastachydium, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Grey_Wolf_c
7	Did you know Christopher Walken was going to appear in a Dune movie? No.	4	3	Vote-able	In Favor: Gwynfrid, Kish, Tzardok, b_jonas Against: Aidan, Grey_Wolf_c, Sir_Norbert
8	Why was Tarquin obsessed with Elan and Nale? He saw extremes of personality.	7	1	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Gwynfrid, Kish, Metastachydium, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok, b_jonas Against: Grey_Wolf_c
9	Do you read the forums anymore? No.	6	2	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Gwynfrid, Kish, Metastachydium, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Grey_Wolf_c, b_jonas
10	Do you speed the plot up after reader feedback? Not anymore.	6	2	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Gwynfrid, Kish, Metastachydium, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Grey_Wolf_c, b_jonas
12	Does Neutrality fit death gods better than Evil? Only sometimes.	6	1	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Gwynfrid, Kish, Metastachydium, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok Against: Grey_Wolf_c
F1	Wrecan is technically a Crusader. ...yes.	9	0	Include	In Favor: Aidan, Grey_Wolf_c, Gwynfrid, Kish, Metastachydium, Ruck, Sir_Norbert, Tzardok, b_jonas Against:

Spoiler: Breakdown by Poster

Show

Poster	1	2	3	4	5	6	7	8	9	10	12	F1
Kish
Ruck
Gwynfrid
Tzardok
Metastachydium
b_jonas
Sir_Norbert
Grey_Wolf_c
Aidan