Quote Originally Posted by Keltest View Post
Because she's in charge and the others arent? Presumably if they live they go join the army that marches off between acts with no further trouble.

This isnt even speculation, this is explicitly what she gets kicked out for.
If you knock out Gut and Ragzlin that's it though. No dressing-down, no performance review, no trial - they just vanish, oresumably dying offscreen. Not that anyone cares, because goblinoid.

I'm not saying Larian made the wrong choice here, far from it. I just think it would have added depth if the other two got tadpoled at least somewhat willingly to explain why they're beyond saving, and how that makes Minthara different. As it is, it's like - "of course she's rescuable, she's a sexy elf, why wouldn't she be? Don't be silly."