Quote Originally Posted by Infernally Clay View Post
This might have been a valid argument in 2002 but it's now 2024 and they've since told us everything we need to know.
Did they release special editions I'm unaware of? Because i specifically said "with the prequels".

It's me, buddy. I am all about Star Wars. I have over 150 of the novels, encompassing Legends and canon. I'm in the 501st, with multiple costumes. I promise you, I'm aware of all the post hoc explanations. That does nothing to address that i feel that the trilogy was horribly done and the fact that it needed post hoc explanations to start with online bolsters that.

Nothing that comes out after the prequel trilogy means that it wasnt a problem in that trilogy. If i write a book and you say "this part doesn't really make sense", sure, i can say that the canon webcomic that has 50 readers explains it, but the webcomic existing doesn't negate that it doesn't make sense in the book.