Star Wars: The Acolyte official trailer

[Errorname]

In this scenario Palpatine will immediately turn on Anakin following killing Mace Windu. Palpatine almost certainly wins that fight.

I am not convinced of this. Anakin in 19 BBY is at the height of his powers and Palpatine has just barely survived a fight with Mace. Palpatine's got a shot, but I wouldn't call it a sure thing.

The Jedi fail to conceive of this as possible, but they don't know squat about bioengineering so that's a blind spot that makes sense.

This makes sense if we ignore that in the arc immediately preceding the Jedi discovering Dooku's hand in the construction of the clone army, a clone went into a fugue state and executed a Jedi, and it was blamed on a "malfunction with his inhibitor chip".

I feel like Clone Wars probably needed to choose between the Sifo-Dyas episode and the Clone Conspiracy arc, because doing both literally back to back makes the Jedi look like complete fools.