Quote Originally Posted by Anonymouswizard View Post
So basically you didn't give him support and were surprised when he got beat to death? As well á apparently not varying their target to get more hits in and leave the PCs carrying around Lethal (or Agg) damage.
Yes. A werewolf against four mortal teenagers with no combat training and improvised weapons should not need support, that is a very surprising outcome to me. I cannot see that outcome occurring in a horror movie, any other RPG I am familiar with including older editions of WoD, or against a similarly sized predator IRL.