Quote Originally Posted by Tom_Violence View Post
Since there's no other details surrounding this, and inventing them defeats the point, there's not much real discussion about this scenario.
The point isn't about discussing the scenario. The point behind the discussion is to talk about the choice. The choice and the reasons behind making them-not making this scenario more illogical than it already is, and not about making it more complicated to avoid the question or making the actual choice.

So yes, you're right, there isn't much discussion about the scenario. Because the scenario is essentially pointless.