![Quote](images/sand/misc/quote_icon.png)
Originally Posted by
NakedCelt
Meh, don't like extra tacked-on elements much. I mean, doesn't fire already produce light? The only "extra" classical element was quintessence, which was considered to be a total mystery since it didn't exist on earth.
I also think it's a bit lacking in imagination to have secondary elements like "magma". If I was creating a secondary element system, it'd go something like this:
Air + Earth: not allowed — the two elements are opposed
Air + Fire: Lightning (because it's like fire from the sky)
Air + Water: Cold (because both wind and water chill you)
Earth + Fire: Metal (because you get metal by smelting rocks in fire)
Earth + Water: Wood (because plants grow when you water the soil)
Fire + Water: not allowed — the two elements are opposed
Could use some tweaking, but that makes more sense to me than "magma, mud, smoke, fog," and whatever.