Originally Posted by
JaxGaret
You can't simply create custom magic items by following the magic item creation guidelines and claim them as RAW-approved items that should be allowed in every campaign.
Think of it this way: custom magic items are not campaign-allowable until DM-approved - instead of your view, which is that any custom magic items that follow the magic item creation guidelines are allowed until the DM disapproves of them.
It just doesn't work like that. DM must approve the item, period.