Quote Originally Posted by Kurald Galain View Post
I'm pretty sure that isn't 2nd ed. Wasn't it unearthed arcana or some similer 1E expansion?

I'm not so sure that "join me or I'll kill you" qualifies as high charisma - and the Dread Necro may be powerful, but is hardly an aphrodisiac to anyone other than Tsuki The best example of a charismatic villain I can think of is actually Melkor.
Really? Huh, guess that was a 2ed house rule (surprise, surprise)

And as for Melkor, he never really struck me as that charismatic. Look at his conduct when Fingolfin challenges him, and tell me he has great internal power and confidence. Now Sauron, there is a confident villain. His manipulation of the Numenoreans pretty much speaks for itself in terms of charisma.