I'm not seeing the CharOp consensus. Could you link to a thread?
EDIT:
I dunno... maybe he has really bad NADs? We've been facing mostly NAD Kickers lately.
I guess my biggest complaint is that they don't actually defend anyone. Heck, every post I've read lauds them for being huge damage dealers - which is the role of the Striker, not the Defender.
Anyhow, next game I plan (IC) to chat with him about battle tactics. One of the benefits of being the bastard child of a Valenar warband leader