Results 1 to 26 of 26
-
2009-01-22, 06:40 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Bristol, UK
- Gender
[Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
NB: This isn't a regular free-for-all anything-goes type thread. I'm going to be blunt and I'm going to be harsh in this post to help define the criteria. That means some people's favourite games will be ruled out from the very start. Sorry if that offends you, but that's life.
We're playing a Star Wars Saga Edition game right now. From the players perspective, it's fun, but I know that's not necessarily the case from the other side of the screen. Our GM has expressed a number of times that he finds it frustrating, his usual calibre of game is towards the direction of freeform. While nothing concrete has been said about a change, he has said he might just say "**** it let's run it with Wushu".
That remains an alternative, but I'd like to see what else there is out there that might work that's perhaps a little crunchier. Why? Because it's less work for the players having to be switched-on and creative all the time. And because so far I think this game has benefitted from having a degree of mechanical distinction between the characters and what they're capable of.
So to be clear, lighter than Saga Edition means no other D20 systems. It means GURPS and HERO are out from the off. It means lighter in all respects, not lighter in some areas, but crunchier in others. If it has a skill list of more than about 15 skills, it's not lighter. If it has more than three categories of special things (Saga has Feats, Talents and Force powers), it's not lighter.
It shouldn't have lots of subsystems built in, because that immediately makes it more complicated than Saga. It shouldn't have an overly involved resolution system, or involve buckets o' dice (small pools are fine, Exalted is not).
It must also be capable of handling both Force-users and non-Force-users. As in balancing the two fairly well, not either nerfing the Force, or making non-Force-users irrelevant. That means D6 is out. It must handle the Force at least as simply as Saga does. D6 with it's "Control, Sense and Alter" is out again for that reason.
Purely from my own perspective (but it might not be shared by either GM or some of the other players), I hate White Wolf's systems. So I'd prefer if people didn't recommend those.
If possible, one corebook should be enough to do the job. I don't think we're averse to indie games, if they're suited to more-than-one-shots. On the other hand, I'm not too keen on DitV's overly complicated mechanics, for reference. Stuff that tends towards the cinematic is obviously better than anything trying to be "realistic".
If it helps at all, there are five players. The PCs comprise a piratical scion of a mining clan, a Twi'lek Jedi, a scout/explorer turned Jedi, a Cerean doctor and a Force-sensetive spy/saboteur. So it must be a game that can handle that many PCs, and allow that amount of distinction. If it only allows single-concept characters (either you're a Jedi or you're not), it's out.
So heavier than Wushu, but lighter than Saga Edition. What is there?Wushu Open Reloaded
Actual Play: The Shadow of the Sun (Acrozatarim's WFRP campaign) as Pawel Hals and Mass: the Effecting - Transcendence as Russell Ortiz.
Now running: Tyche's Favourites, a historical ACKS campaign set around Massalia 300BC.
In Sanity We Trust Productions - our podcasting site where you can hear our dulcet tones, updated almost every week.
-
2009-01-22, 07:01 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2007
- Location
- Norway
- Gender
-
2009-01-22, 07:15 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Location
- Koth
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
HeroQuest from Issaries, Inc. All you need is the resolution system, which takes up a few pages. There's no mechanical difference between skills, and there's no skill lists - you can have any skill/ability you want (but Master Swordsman is no more useful than Close Combat/Swords in combat), and you can use them for anything that the GM and other players don't object to. As far as the resolution system is concerned, you could have a contest of Oratory and Punch People Dead skills. The Force would easily be handled as a set of affinities and feats - the three affinities being Alter, Control, and Sense, obviously. Nobody would be a Devotee, and everyone would have to "purchase" the Force feats normally.
You'll have to write up your own Keywords, but that's no problem at all.
Balance would exist to the degree that common sense allows. Alter / Force Thrust would be mechanically identical to Shove People Around in combat etc., but obviously the Force would be easier to use in weird ways. (I'd probably limit augmenting with the Force to one feat per contest.)
As a bonus, you get an awesome game set in the most awesome and magical fantasy setting ever. If you don't feel like playing it in the default setting after reading the book, I'll eat a shoe.
-
2009-01-22, 07:30 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2008
- Location
- Under your bed. :P
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
You could forget about rules and just have a "No, my dude can do this" competition that 5 year olds usually play. I find the D20 system to be a very light, simple and flexible. I don't know why you would want to dumb it down any more than it is.
perhaps your DM is having trouble keeping you to a stuck course so that the game will turn out exactly the way he wants it? I'd suggest just playing on the fly, as that has turned out pretty well for some of the DMs in my group.
-
2009-01-22, 07:34 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2008
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Fudge.
Availiable free online as an SRD, Fudge is a system designed to let you make any system you want out of it. The size of the rules looks intimidating at first, but that's only because they actually consist of a whole bunch of variants, options, and advice for choosing the rules that best suit your playstyle, setting, and characters. I'd estimate that a final version of the rule set, once decided on by the GM and edited down, would only consist of 5 printed pages, with a little extra in your case to allow for defining how the Force works.
Why Fudge?
Simple character creation - there are Attributes (defined by the GM), Skills (any you can make up, subject to GM approval and tweaking), Gifts (benefits that aren't attributes or skills, make up your own), and Faults (like gifts, but negative). That's it. No looking through lists of feats and powers.
Balance: Fudge can be tweaked to have any kind of balance you want. For example, simply increasing the cost of force powers relative to other skills will force people to think about trade offs, because everything comes from the same pool of points at character creation.
Anywho, check out the srd. Then again, it might not be heavy enough for your tastes. It makes a great base to build on, thoughLast edited by Edge of Dreams; 2009-01-22 at 07:36 AM.
I spent an hour on the edge of dreams,
I walked between the worlds,
and when I woke I never knew
to which side I had fallen
-
2009-01-22, 07:36 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Bristol, UK
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
I've done my own for Feng Shui, too. It's a possibility, but it has problems of it's own (the core mechanic being a prime one).
I think a problem with HQ is going to be Extended Contests. That's a pretty involved bit of meta-mechanics which may turn out even more complicated in it's own way.
You know when I said "crunchier than Wushu"? Freeform isn't an option, I don't think that would work for anyone. We already know Wushu works better than freeform. And D20 is far from "light"; if you think it's the definition of simplicity, then it speaks more to your lack of experience with other systems.
Trust me, "not heavy enough" is unlikely to be an issue, as I said the alternative is Wushu. But we'd like a little more differentiation than that.
What's the difference between Fudge and Fate? Has someone done a Fudge/Star Wars adaptation already?Last edited by Kiero; 2009-01-22 at 07:43 AM.
Wushu Open Reloaded
Actual Play: The Shadow of the Sun (Acrozatarim's WFRP campaign) as Pawel Hals and Mass: the Effecting - Transcendence as Russell Ortiz.
Now running: Tyche's Favourites, a historical ACKS campaign set around Massalia 300BC.
In Sanity We Trust Productions - our podcasting site where you can hear our dulcet tones, updated almost every week.
-
2009-01-22, 07:46 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2008
- Location
- Under your bed. :P
-
2009-01-22, 07:48 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2008
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Fate is based on Fudge, but other than that, I dunno. Spirit of the Century is an example of a great game that took Fudge and picked certain options, threw out others, and tacked on a bit of its own thing.
As far as I know, no official Fudge/Star Wars game exists, but I wouldn't be surprised if someone, somewhere, has done it.I spent an hour on the edge of dreams,
I walked between the worlds,
and when I woke I never knew
to which side I had fallen
-
2009-01-22, 08:15 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2005
- Location
- Flawse Fell, Geordieland
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
A "Star Wars" system lighter than SWd20 or Saggy? WEG's SW d6 should work for you.
A little scratching about in some of the more wretched hives of scum and villainy of the webtertubes (ie: ebay) should turn up cheap old copies.
-
2009-01-22, 08:25 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Location
- UTC -6
-
2009-01-22, 08:37 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Bristol, UK
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Last edited by Kiero; 2009-01-22 at 08:38 AM.
Wushu Open Reloaded
Actual Play: The Shadow of the Sun (Acrozatarim's WFRP campaign) as Pawel Hals and Mass: the Effecting - Transcendence as Russell Ortiz.
Now running: Tyche's Favourites, a historical ACKS campaign set around Massalia 300BC.
In Sanity We Trust Productions - our podcasting site where you can hear our dulcet tones, updated almost every week.
-
2009-01-22, 08:45 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Location
- Koth
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
I'm not sure how it's complicated. You bid, you roll, you repeat until someone's out of points. This can be used to handle fighting a hundred enemies at once, if you feel like going up against a four-digit point pool...
It's definitely the simplest combat resolution system I'm familiar with, and the action is entirely descriptive, not tactical.
-
2009-01-22, 08:55 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- England
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
How about BRP? I like that system. Percentile skills, very few real crunch elements, but crunchy enough to handle any situation. I don't like really rules-light/freeform systems, as having something solid is a good thing for me. Balance is determined by the GM, not the system, too, so you can adjust it as you like.
Magic in BRP is likewise very flexible. You could exchange Magic Points for Force Points, and the augmentations could cost 1MP for +X% to a skill, and stranger powers could just be spells in themselves. You can even say that you need X POW to use force powers (and have a Force Point pool), or simply give your players an extra skill, and tell them:
"Use the Force" is a skill if you want to Use the Force. Force Sensitivity is another. You must roll Use the Force if you want to use a Force Power. If successful, you gain one of the following effects:
- Bonus to the skill roll if used at the same time. (1MP)
- Extra dice of damage if used like Martial Arts (2MP)
- A use of a Force Power [spell] (varies)
Yeah, BRP. You may have to do some homebrewing for races and junk, but hey, I bet someone's already done it.
-
2009-01-22, 08:57 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2005
- Location
- Flawse Fell, Geordieland
-
2009-01-22, 09:28 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Bristol, UK
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Wushu Open Reloaded
Actual Play: The Shadow of the Sun (Acrozatarim's WFRP campaign) as Pawel Hals and Mass: the Effecting - Transcendence as Russell Ortiz.
Now running: Tyche's Favourites, a historical ACKS campaign set around Massalia 300BC.
In Sanity We Trust Productions - our podcasting site where you can hear our dulcet tones, updated almost every week.
-
2009-01-22, 10:04 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2008
- Location
- Koth
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
It is an abstraction, yes, but I don't think you'll find a light system that isn't. I mean, the only non-abstract combat system I can think of is in The Riddle of Steel, where ten seconds of combat takes half an hour (a great half-hour, full of tactical decisions, and when someone gets hit, it's pretty decisive) - and even TRoS is somewhat abstract.
I'm not sure I see how the bidding can be complex.
You bid points from your pool. You roll dice. As a result, either you lose points, or your opponent loses points. (Or both of you, or one loses and one gains, etc.)
Meanwhile, you're describing what's going on. If you bid everything you had, then clearly you're making a risky gambit - an all-out attack, a everything-on-the-table revelation or putting your own character on the line in a social situation, etc. If you bid very little, you're being cautious, maybe just setting up for an advantageous position or probing your opponent.
Once someone runs out of points, they're defeated - the degree depends on whether they went into the negatives and how badly.
-
2009-01-22, 10:45 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2005
- Location
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Serenity; it's still one of my favourite rules-light systems. I've used it for a Medieval game before. You just ignore costing and economic stuff; really, that stuff you could pull from the saga book and translate it (or have your DM offload that to someone. offloading world creation... i want to do that next time.). General resolution is attribute + skill (no lists) + plot points. Resolution numbers are easy, too.
I'd recommend making force powers cost a certain number of plot points to even use, except in DM mandated situations.
Of course, failing that, there's always the basic WoD skill system; don't take combat, just skills and attributes and resolution. You don't need anything beyond that for light. (in fact, you could do that with D&D even; it's just the d&D skill system suffers from some flaws that making it the center of a game would only emphasize.
-
2009-01-22, 12:35 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Bristol, UK
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
A note from the GM in question:
Originally Posted by DaveBWushu Open Reloaded
Actual Play: The Shadow of the Sun (Acrozatarim's WFRP campaign) as Pawel Hals and Mass: the Effecting - Transcendence as Russell Ortiz.
Now running: Tyche's Favourites, a historical ACKS campaign set around Massalia 300BC.
In Sanity We Trust Productions - our podcasting site where you can hear our dulcet tones, updated almost every week.
-
2009-01-22, 12:37 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Bristol, UK
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
I play and enjoy Wushu, it's not like abstraction itself is an issue. But when it doesn't feel intuitive or natural then it is. I've heard someone say in the past if you're familiar with poker, then HQ's bidding system is pretty straightforward. Well I'm not, so it doesn't feel simple at all.
Wushu Open Reloaded
Actual Play: The Shadow of the Sun (Acrozatarim's WFRP campaign) as Pawel Hals and Mass: the Effecting - Transcendence as Russell Ortiz.
Now running: Tyche's Favourites, a historical ACKS campaign set around Massalia 300BC.
In Sanity We Trust Productions - our podcasting site where you can hear our dulcet tones, updated almost every week.
-
2009-01-22, 12:59 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2007
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
It could be worth checking out Powergame. It's meant for Superhero stuff, but it's pretty flexible.
A System-Independent Creative Community:
Strolen's Citadel
-
2009-01-22, 01:13 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2006
- Location
- Fairfield, CA
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Everway. Sure, the base setting is that of your typical fantasy planeswalking schtick, but the core mechanics are simple and intuitive.
There are no dice: all action is resolved by DM fiat or by a draw from the tarot deck when the DM can't make the decision himself.
There are four statistics: Earth (representing physical and mental stamina, practicality, and overall endurance); Air (representing intelligence, agility, and creativity); Fire (representing power, passion and drive); and Water (representing perception, wisdom, and patience). Each range between 1 and 10. Determining who is the victor in a trial of skill amounts to comparing one person's score to another: the higher wins.
Magic can be refluffed as The Force easily. Magic is also rated on a 1-10 scale, and the example paths given are largely described as "higher numbers allow a larger scope of effect". In short, you make up your magic as you go along, and the DM adjucates as needed.
Powers, which are different from magic, are physical abilities or special equipment. These cost between 0 to 3 points of your character creation pool, with the score depending on if the power is Frequently Usable, Powerful, or Versatile. Being a force-wielder, for instance, would be a 3 point power (as it is frequent, versatile, and powerful); a lightsaber would be a 2 point power (as it is frequent and powerful, but not versatile); a blaster would be a 1 point power (as it is frequent, but not powerful or versatile); a resistance to heat would be a 0 point power ( as it is not frequent, powerful, or versatile).
I'd highly suggest checking it out: even if it'd take a little bit of effort to make the game's mechanics do exactly what you want them to do, they are capable of doing it out of the box with almost no effort.Last edited by Fax Celestis; 2009-01-22 at 01:15 PM.
Wiki - Q&A - FB - LIn - Tw
d20r Compilation PDF - last updated 9.11.14
d20r: Spells (I-L) - d20r: Spells (H) - d20r: Spells (G) - d20r: Spells (F) - d20r: Spells (E) - d20r: Spells (D) - d20r: Wizard class
-
2009-01-22, 01:47 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2007
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
So how about Spirit of the Century?
Just replace the War/Novel/Guest Star phases of character generation with something more appropriate for Star Wars.
There is also an online coversion to SciFi, Spirit of the Far Future, which, although its set up as a version of Traveller, gives a nice example of Spirit of the Century as a SciFi game.
Spirit of the Century SRD
Spirit of the Far Future
-
2009-01-22, 02:02 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2008
- Location
- Vancouver WA
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
I second the suggestion for Feng Shui.
Not sure what your problems with the system are, but by just excluding all the powers and archtypes that don't make sense it would be an easy and good fit.
Short of that coming up with a not-quite free form homebrew might be another option, just going to take some work from the GM to get it where he wants it.Battle Aura by Tavin Mars
SpoilerI Will Not Stand By
I Will Not Give Up
I Will Let My Presence Be Felt
To The Utmost of My Ability
Regardless Of The Battle
I Shall Fight
-
2009-01-22, 02:06 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2007
- Location
- Fishtown, Germany
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
All Flesh Must Be Eaten + All Tomorow Zombies. All Unisystem goodness, including a star wars based setting.
The rules are light and easy to learn, the different characters are adaptable and easy to adjust (no painfully hidebound class limitations).
The base system has a somewhat more specifc list of skills, but since it is absolutely no problem to use the ATZ specific stuff together with the cinematic Unisystem, which is much simpler.
-
2009-01-22, 06:54 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Location
- Bristol, UK
- Gender
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Wushu Open Reloaded
Actual Play: The Shadow of the Sun (Acrozatarim's WFRP campaign) as Pawel Hals and Mass: the Effecting - Transcendence as Russell Ortiz.
Now running: Tyche's Favourites, a historical ACKS campaign set around Massalia 300BC.
In Sanity We Trust Productions - our podcasting site where you can hear our dulcet tones, updated almost every week.
-
2009-01-22, 07:57 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2007
Re: [Star Wars] Recommend a system lighter than Saga Edition
Some thoughts on the subject, at least.
As far as I can tell from looking at other stuff, though, Spirit of the Force was never really written down:
http://forum.rpg.net/showthread.php?t=314060A System-Independent Creative Community:
Strolen's Citadel